Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow Review: My Honest Experience

I was initially intrigued by the buzz around Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow and Honey Balm, a product marketed as a natural, all-in-one moisturizer. With claims of deep hydration and suitability for all skin types, it sounded like a game-changer for my sensitive skin. However, after diving into my experience and weighing the pros and cons, I’m not convinced this is worth your money. The bad reviews I found online, coupled with my own results, suggest you might want to look elsewhere for skincare solutions. Let’s break down my journey and why this product fell short.

My Experience with Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow

When I first heard about beef tallow skincare, I was skeptical but curious. The idea of slathering cow fat on my face felt bizarre, yet the promise of natural hydration and nutrient-rich ingredients like Manuka honey and grass-fed tallow pulled me in. I purchased the Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow and Honey Balm, a 4.23-ounce jar, hoping for soft, glowing skin. The packaging was simple, and the instructions were clear: warm a small amount in your palms, apply to clean skin, and massage until absorbed.

The first thing I noticed was the texture—or lack thereof. Unlike the creamy, whipped consistency I expected, the balm was oddly watery. It didn’t feel luxurious; it was more like rubbing diluted lotion on my face. The scent was another letdown. While Evil Goods claims it’s unscented, there was a faint, meaty odor that lingered, making my skincare routine less than pleasant. I applied it twice daily, as suggested, hoping the hydration would kick in.

After a week, my skin felt slightly softer but not significantly moisturized. My dry patches persisted, and I noticed a greasy film on my face that didn’t absorb well, especially during the day under makeup. By week two, small bumps appeared on my cheeks—likely clogged pores, a common issue with tallow for acne-prone skin like mine. I checked the ingredient list and was shocked to see water listed first, with tallow as one of the last ingredients. This explained the watery consistency and lack of potency. The bad reviews I read online echoed my experience, with many calling it a “cheap knockoff” that didn’t deliver.

I wanted to love this product, especially given the hype around tallow’s skin-loving vitamins (A, D, E, K). But the poor formulation and lackluster results left me disappointed. My skin didn’t transform, and the greasy residue and breakouts made me ditch it. I switched back to my trusted plant-based moisturizer, which worked better without the hassle.

Pros and Cons of Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow

Pros of Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow

Natural Ingredients: The balm includes grass-fed beef tallow, Manuka honey, and organic olive oil, which are free from synthetic chemicals like parabens and phthalates. These components can theoretically nourish skin with vitamins and fatty acids.
Versatile Use: It’s marketed for face, body, hands, and lips, making it a multi-purpose product. I found it mildly soothing on dry elbows, though not transformative.
Sensitive Skin Claim: Evil Goods touts suitability for sensitive skin, and the lack of essential oils reduces irritation risk for some users.
Eco-Conscious Appeal: Using tallow repurposes a beef industry byproduct, appealing to those who value sustainable, zero-waste products.

Cons of Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow

Watery Consistency: Unlike the promised “whipped” texture, the balm is thin and liquid-like, making it feel cheap and ineffective. Many reviews confirm this, noting it’s mostly water, with tallow barely present in the formula.
Weak Moisturization: Despite claims of deep hydration, it didn’t relieve my dry skin. The greasy film it left behind felt heavy without penetrating deeply, leaving my face shiny and uncomfortable.
Unpleasant Scent: The “unscented” claim is misleading. A subtle, meaty odor persists, which was off-putting during application and lingered on my skin, making it hard to enjoy.
Clogs Pores: My acne-prone skin developed small bumps after two weeks, likely due to tallow’s comedogenic nature. Dermatologists warn that tallow can trap oils and debris, worsening acne for oily or sensitive skin types.
Questionable Ingredient Quality: The ingredient list prioritizes water over tallow, suggesting a diluted product. This contradicts the premium, grass-fed tallow branding and reduces efficacy compared to pure tallow balms.
High Price for Low Value: At around $30-$50 for 4.23 ounces, it’s pricey for a product that underperforms. Competing brands offer richer, more effective tallow balms at similar or lower prices.
Potential Health Risks: Some dermatologists raise concerns about contamination risks, like bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), in poorly sourced tallow. While Evil Goods claims grass-fed sources, the lack of transparency on processing is worrisome.
Not Vegan-Friendly: The animal-derived tallow makes it unsuitable for vegans or those with ethical concerns about animal products, limiting its appeal.
Photosensitivity Risk: Studies suggest high-concentration tallow can increase sun sensitivity, potentially causing irritation or damage if used without sunscreen.

The cons heavily outweigh the pros here. The watery formula and minimal tallow content make it feel like a scam, especially when you’re paying for a premium product. If you’re set on trying tallow, I’d recommend a brand with a purer, thicker consistency and better transparency. For me, the breakouts and greasy residue were dealbreakers, and I can’t justify the cost for such lackluster results.

Maintenance Tips for Using Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow

If you decide to give Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow a shot despite its flaws, proper use and storage are key to getting the most out of it. Here’s how to make it work as best as possible, based on my experience and research.

Patch Test First: Before slathering it on your face, test a small amount on your inner arm or behind your ear. Tallow can be comedogenic, and my breakouts proved it’s not for everyone. Wait 24-48 hours to check for redness, bumps, or irritation. If your skin reacts poorly, skip it—your face will thank you.
Use Sparingly: A little goes a long way, especially since this balm is greasy. I made the mistake of applying too much, which left my skin shiny and clogged my pores. Warm a pea-sized amount in your palms until it melts, then gently massage it into clean, slightly damp skin. This helps it absorb better and reduces the oily residue.
Apply at Night: The greasy finish and meaty scent make daytime use tricky, especially under makeup. I found it worked better as a nighttime moisturizer. Apply after cleansing, let it sink in, and wash it off in the morning to avoid a slick look during the day. This also minimizes photosensitivity risks, as tallow can make skin more sun-sensitive.
Store Properly: Tallow is temperature-sensitive and can go rancid if not stored correctly. Keep the jar sealed in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Evil Goods recommends avoiding heat, as I learned when my jar started smelling funkier after being left near a sunny window. Refrigeration can extend shelf life but makes the balm hard to spread—warm it slightly before use.
Cleanse Thoroughly: The occlusive nature of tallow can trap dirt and oils, so double-cleansing is a must, especially if you’re acne-prone like me. Use an oil-based cleanser followed by a gentle foaming cleanser to remove all residue. This prevents clogged pores and keeps your skin clear.
Monitor Skin Reactions: Check your skin weekly for signs of breakouts or dehydration. My skin felt tight and oily simultaneously after prolonged use, a sign the formula wasn’t balanced for me. If you notice similar issues, scale back or stop using it. Consult a dermatologist if irritation persists.
Combine with Lightweight Products: To counter the greasy feel, layer a lightweight, non-comedogenic moisturizer over the tallow for daytime use. I mixed it with a hyaluronic acid serum, which helped dilute the heaviness and boosted hydration without clogging pores.

By following these tips, you might mitigate some of the product’s downsides, but honestly, the effort felt like too much for the minimal benefits I got.

Comparison of Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallowwith Other Beef Tallow Brands

Vintage Tradition Tallow Balm

Vintage Tradition’s Tallow Balm is a standout for its thick, creamy texture and pure, grass-fed tallow base. Unlike Evil Goods’ watery formula, this balm feels rich and absorbs well, leaving my dry elbows soft without greasiness. It blends tallow with non-comedogenic oils like jojoba, making it less likely to clog pores for acne-prone skin. The unscented version has a mild, natural scent that’s far less off-putting than Evil Goods. Priced around $25 for 2 ounces, it’s a better value for its potency. However, it’s still animal-derived, so vegans should steer clear. Overall, it’s a more reliable tallow option.

Genesis Tallow Face Whip

Genesis Tallow Face Whip combines grass-fed tallow with hemp-seed oil for a lightweight, nourishing balm. I found its texture airier than Evil Goods, with better absorption and no greasy residue. It’s great for sensitive skin, as the essential-oil-free version minimizes irritation. At $35 for 2 ounces, it’s pricier but feels premium. My skin felt smoother after a week, though it didn’t fully hydrate my driest patches. The brand’s transparency on sourcing is reassuring, unlike Evil Goods’ vague claims. It’s a solid choice for tallow fans but requires careful storage to avoid rancidity.

Soft n’ Fat Calendula Chamomile Whipped Tallow

Soft n’ Fat’s Whipped Tallow, endorsed by Rumer Willis, blends tallow with calendula and chamomile for soothing benefits. Its creamy texture trumps Evil Goods’ runny formula, and the subtle herbal scent is pleasant. Priced at $39 for 4 ounces, it’s versatile for face and body, delivering decent hydration for my dry hands. However, the essential oils might irritate sensitive skin, and it’s not ideal for oily complexions. It didn’t clog my pores, but I needed a thorough cleanse to remove it. It’s a luxurious option but not a must-have.

Hearth and Homestead Whipped Tallow

Hearth and Homestead’s Whipped Tallow is a favorite on Amazon for its light, whipped consistency and pure tallow base. At $20 for 2 ounces, it’s budget-friendly and outperforms Evil Goods in hydration. My skin felt soft without the greasy film, and the neutral scent was barely noticeable. It’s great for body use but felt too heavy for my face, causing minor breakouts. The brand’s small-batch production ensures quality, but availability can be spotty. If you’re curious about tallow, this is a safer bet than Evil Goods for the price.

Nefertem Naturals Tallow Skincare

Nefertem Naturals offers a tallow balm with a proprietary rendering process that minimizes the beefy smell, a huge plus over Evil Goods. Priced at $30 for 2 ounces, it’s thick and hydrating, perfect for dry or eczema-prone skin. I loved how it softened my cuticles, though it was too occlusive for my face, leading to clogged pores. The brand emphasizes regenerative farming, appealing to eco-conscious buyers. It’s not vegan-friendly, and the texture can feel heavy in humid climates. Still, it’s a high-quality alternative with better results than Evil Goods.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Why do dermatologists not recommend tallow?

Dermatologists often caution against beef tallow due to its comedogenic nature, which can clog pores and worsen acne, especially for oily or sensitive skin. There’s limited clinical research supporting its efficacy compared to regulated skincare ingredients like hyaluronic acid or ceramides. Concerns about contamination, such as bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), and inconsistent sourcing also raise red flags. Tallow’s occlusive properties may trap debris, leading to irritation, and some studies suggest it increases photosensitivity, making skin more prone to sun damage. Dermatologists prefer ingredients with proven safety and efficacy over trendy, unregulated options.

Why was beef tallow banned?

Beef tallow itself isn’t banned, but its use in cosmetics faced scrutiny in the 1990s due to bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), or mad cow disease. Fears of transmitting variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease (vCJD) to humans through animal-derived products led to stricter regulations in some regions, particularly in Europe. While not outright banned, tallow in skincare must meet rigorous safety standards, and many brands switched to plant-based alternatives for consistency and consumer trust. Today, reputable tallow products use grass-fed, carefully sourced ingredients to mitigate risks, but transparency remains critical.

Is beef tallow actually good for you?

Beef tallow can be beneficial for some, thanks to its fatty acids (oleic, stearic, palmitic) and vitamins (A, D, E, K), which mimic skin’s sebum and support the skin barrier. It’s deeply moisturizing for dry or eczema-prone skin and may soothe inflammation in conditions like psoriasis. However, it’s not a cure-all. For acne-prone or oily skin, it’s often too heavy, causing clogged pores or breakouts. Risks like photosensitivity and contamination also exist. While it’s nutrient-rich, plant-based alternatives like jojoba oil often provide similar benefits without the ethical or health concerns.

Is whipped beef tallow good for skin?

Whipped beef tallow can hydrate dry skin due to its lipid-rich profile, making it a decent option for eczema or mature skin. Its vitamins and fatty acids may strengthen the skin barrier and reduce inflammation. However, it’s not ideal for everyone. For oily or acne-prone skin, whipped tallow’s occlusive nature can clog pores, leading to breakouts, as I experienced. The scent and greasy feel can also be off-putting. While some swear by it, dermatologists suggest patch-testing and consulting a professional, as lighter, non-comedogenic moisturizers often work better for most skin types.

Final Thoughts

After weeks of testing, I can’t recommend Evil Goods Whipped Beef Tallow and Honey Balm. The watery consistency, minimal tallow content, and greasy residue were major letdowns, especially for the price. Bad reviews calling it a “knockoff” align with my experience—it just doesn’t deliver the hydration or nourishment promised. Compared to brands like Vintage Tradition or Hearth and Homestead, it falls short in quality and efficacy. My breakouts and the meaty scent sealed the deal: this product isn’t worth your time or money. Stick to plant-based moisturizers or purer tallow balms for better results.